Tap to unmute

The bridge that must legally wobble

Compartilhar
Incorporar
  • Publicado em 17 Abr 2022
  • "Daly's Bridge", in Cork, Ireland, is better known as the Shakey Bridge. Because it shakes. But what happens when a bridge like that has to be repaired and refurbished? • Thanks to Cllr McCarthy: his site is corkheritage.ie/ !
    Edited by Dave Stevenson davestevenson.co.uk
    A thorough study of how the Bridge shakes: publish.ucc.ie/boolean/pdf/201... [PDF]
    I did try (a lot!) to get an interview with someone from RPS Group, who were in charge of the refurbishment, but I just wasn't able to make contact. However, I'm indebted to Michael Minehane, principal engineer, whose talk to Engineers Ireland gives a lot of in-depth information about the bridge was refurbished! You can watch it here, along with Cllr McCarthy's history of the bridge: www.youtube.com/watch?v=j52po...
    Thanks to Youssuf Radwan for the suggestion!
    I'm at tomscott.com
    on Twitter at tomscott
    on Facebook at tomscott
    and on Instagram as tomscottgo

Comentários • 2 218

  • Tom Scott
    Tom Scott  5 meses atrás +5875

    Pull down the description for my sources on this video: if you'd like to know more, there's an hour-long panel talk discussing the bridge's history and refurbishment from Engineers Ireland!

    • Jul W
      Jul W Mês atrás

      @CryingAutumn Oh you don't say?

    • Raoul Duke
      Raoul Duke Mês atrás

      @Kairav Shah poo poo piiii poo iiiiī

    • SpiritSlayer
      SpiritSlayer 3 meses atrás

      Hi

    • POW Muckerstion
      POW Muckerstion 4 meses atrás

      You think this a shaky bridge boy you haven’t seen one like the one my family made to get to the family cabin over probably 100 feet above a river

    • jobaer likhon
      jobaer likhon 5 meses atrás

      ok

  • ObviouslyBenHughes
    ObviouslyBenHughes 5 meses atrás +15879

    The joy I felt seeing some adult jumping like a child in the middle of the bridge exactly when the guest was speaking about people having fun doing just that, good stuff.

    • Armide Suárez Luzardo
      Armide Suárez Luzardo 2 meses atrás

      @Patata That kind of hints that he does it everyday

    • l o l
      l o l 3 meses atrás

      You didn't finish your sentence.

    • Brandon Brooks
      Brandon Brooks 4 meses atrás

      Agreed.

    • DarkXTC
      DarkXTC 5 meses atrás +2

      my personal opinion? If i ever stop acting like a child for things like swings or shaky bridges? shoot me on the spot because i already died inside at that point.

    • BuriedFlame
      BuriedFlame 5 meses atrás +1

      *Mario jump sfx*

  • Paul Drake
    Paul Drake 5 meses atrás +3847

    Current era: "We need to hire engineers, surveyors, fabricators, it's gonna cost about 10 million euros."
    A hundred years ago: "Dude, we can order a bridge from this catalog. 700 pounds."

    • AgentPothead
      AgentPothead 11 dias atrás

      And that bridge from a hundred years ago will probably be in operation longer than the ones we make now.

    • Nielsbishere
      Nielsbishere 14 dias atrás

      700£ in 1930 is still 32k£ in 2021 and probably more in 2022

    • BeccaB Bea
      BeccaB Bea Mês atrás

      @c smith Unfortunately it would probably be delivered to the next town (rather like my stuff being delivered down the road to the unoccupied house). Then the boxes would just have been way too big and stuffed with brown paper.

    • Pasha
      Pasha Mês atrás

      The catalog was probably prefab.
      That's the difference between custom-made and mass-manufactured.

    • Robert Ross
      Robert Ross 2 meses atrás

      @hausaffe and they screw up too.
      locally they replaced a bridge across a small river, a bit wider than the river in the video, they used a government approved design that was in use for decades and hired experienced engineering company to do the work .
      after a year the driving surface was cracked and warped and the transition from bridge to land was heaving amd sinking.
      Turns out that design of bridge had never been used over water.. even though all the authorities and know it alls said it was approved.

  • Oskar Rasmussen
    Oskar Rasmussen 4 meses atrás +1304

    Daly's Brige patch notes:
    -Fixed corosion
    -New cables and overall updated graphics
    -"Bouncing bug" now officially a feature.

    • Myth
      Myth Mês atrás

      This bridge is Fnaf security breach of bridges

    • keith pendegraft
      keith pendegraft Mês atrás

      The got a video game company to fix it

    • DJ_Level_3
      DJ_Level_3 2 meses atrás +4

      - updated localization files

    • Levi For Waifu
      Levi For Waifu 2 meses atrás +2

      Rocket Jumping.mp4

    • LitoMikeM1 YT
      LitoMikeM1 YT 2 meses atrás +8

      apparently epic games said they would pay Daly Bridge to add toxic nine year olds

  • Real Engineering
    Real Engineering 5 meses atrás +3171

    Ooooh Tom Scott does Ireland. Looking forward to seeing what you make

    • Can Avar
      Can Avar 5 meses atrás +4

      I used to live just a 3 or four gardens up from this bridge on Sundays Well Road. I could see the bridge from my bedroom and walked across it many a times. Thanks for taking me down memory lane!

    • Noel
      Noel 5 meses atrás +1

      What you make?

    • Christian Melucci
      Christian Melucci 5 meses atrás +11

      Isee it coming: "the insane engineering of the wobbly bridge"

    • Diago767
      Diago767 5 meses atrás +11

      Colab comming? Nudge nudge wink wink 😁

    • Lewis Glover
      Lewis Glover 5 meses atrás +27

      I think the world could do with a Real Engineering Tom Scott crossover video

  • Eoin Peacock
    Eoin Peacock 5 meses atrás +1490

    as a cork girI I was devastated when I heard the bridge was going to be repaired. visited a couple weeks after it went back up and was thrilled at the bounce

    • Punnamaraju Vinayaka Tejas
      Punnamaraju Vinayaka Tejas 6 dias atrás +1

      So I was imagining something like:
      Engineering company: We will fix this bridge so that it will last another 100 years, AND we will fix the wobble
      Government: It's a heritage site mate, it has to be preserved in its initial condition
      Engg. Coy: Really? Is the wobble important?
      All the people: WE WANT THE WOBBLE

    • john sometimes wrong
      john sometimes wrong 3 meses atrás

      @Golf Nut
      Always respectfull ...😁...

    • Golf Nut
      Golf Nut 3 meses atrás +4

      @john sometimes wrong OR... do Cork girls bounce nicely... (Said in a respectful manner.)

    • john sometimes wrong
      john sometimes wrong 3 meses atrás +12

      I heard that cork girls like a bounce😁

    • Deadpan Barry
      Deadpan Barry 4 meses atrás +26

      Hello fellow Cork person.... Did the same and wasn't disappointed. 🇮🇪

  • Insert Channel Name Here
    Insert Channel Name Here 5 meses atrás +1291

    Fun Fact: The restoration of that bridge cost 1.7 million euros, a full 34 times more expensive than the inflation-adjusted cost to build the original bridge.

    • Snazzy Jovial Wyrm
      Snazzy Jovial Wyrm 26 dias atrás +2

      @Robert Talada The issue is that protected buildings cannot be completely torn down and replaced with something new. There are legal and social repercussions for it.

    • Katrina Bryce
      Katrina Bryce Mês atrás +4

      @MyTech The original was a mass-produced catalogue bridge. The repair would require custom machined parts.

    • Gandalf
      Gandalf  Mês atrás

      @MyTech It's more like they have redefined the term inflation to mean something it doesn't.

    • John Smith
      John Smith 3 meses atrás +1

      @flexiblebird In all fairness, if you build something expensive thats built to last, its probably gonna be unique in alot of ways, aka quirks, now that means those quirks 90 years from now have to be accounted for, dealt with, all the while the dickheads who built the thing 90 years ago just said to themselves, “if it works for 90 years then when it does break itll be some other assholes problem hope theyre prepared”.

    • MyTech
      MyTech 3 meses atrás +1

      @BluezZ No, they really aren't. Unless maybe you zoom out all the way to the level of "We have a pile of metal and some tools to put the metal together. "

  • Wei Tzu Chin
    Wei Tzu Chin 5 meses atrás +1356

    I love the fact that the engineers took effort and ran simulations to make sure that the wobble stays as close to the original bridge as possible.

    • Dex
      Dex 2 meses atrás +3

      @mmw computers to run the simulations cost money, the electricity flowing through the computer center costs money, and the developers who made the simulation need to be paid for their work and equipment. Costing more than 50k actually isn’t impossible, although the amount of money spent is probably lower than 50k because they probably used already existing software and hardware.

    • integr8er66
      integr8er66 4 meses atrás

      Ya but were you willing to pay the millions it cost, or do you approve because somebody else paid

    • mmw
      mmw 4 meses atrás +5

      @Count Luke computer simulations cost nothing

    • iWatchWithNoAds
      iWatchWithNoAds 4 meses atrás +6

      @Count Luke no it was most probably done by an intern

    • sang vo ba
      sang vo ba 4 meses atrás

      ok

  • Julian Lineham
    Julian Lineham 5 meses atrás +813

    As a structural engineer I loved this one and respected the community’s wish to keep their bridge behaving as it used to. Credit to the new engineers too!

  • Namae
    Namae 5 meses atrás +285

    I'm an Irish engineering student with an upcoming exam in mechanical vibrations and keeping the shaky bridge shaky goes against everything I have ever learned. I wish I could have been involved.

    • scarylion.roar
      scarylion.roar 3 meses atrás

      Alice? More rigid bridge?

    • Rennie Ash
      Rennie Ash 3 meses atrás +1

      It's not so much against everything you learnt as you're only going against the "reduce oscillation" part of it. All structures have harmonics and resonance, which you calculate. You then don't fix it, just make sure it won't break :)

    • lambdaman
      lambdaman 4 meses atrás +5

      I'm glad you weren't involved. I don't want you engineering in ways that go against everything you have ever learned.

    • Satoru
      Satoru 4 meses atrás +27

      @bouytt guyt The funniest part is the common modern joke "I got a bridge to sell you" used to be reality.

  • festive obeliskus
    festive obeliskus 5 meses atrás +3464

    Kinda wholesome that the local residents got a say in the preservation of the bridge. A lot of them must've spent their childhoods boppin' up and down it. :)

    • Gerhard Smith
      Gerhard Smith 4 meses atrás +1

      @Jonathan Odude
      I agree, but that doesn't say anything about people in Ireland "having a bigger say"

    • Jonathan Odude
      Jonathan Odude 4 meses atrás

      @Gerhard Smith saying no to a new project is always more of a big deal than saying yes. the people saying no might change their mind if you move it 10m or rotate it or cover it up with something. meanwhile, nothing is lost if you dont proceed because it didnt exist beforehand.

    • Gerhard Smith
      Gerhard Smith 5 meses atrás +1

      @DiarmuidShanks "three people complained and shut a project that the majority supported" isn't having a bigger say than in other places

    • DiarmuidShanks
      DiarmuidShanks 5 meses atrás

      @Gerhard Smith What?

    • Gerhard Smith
      Gerhard Smith 5 meses atrás +4

      @DiarmuidShanks
      That's not having a "bigger say" if a minority defeats a majority

  • Jim Murphy
    Jim Murphy 5 meses atrás +241

    The idea of picking a bridge from a catalog, and having it show up flat packed, Ikea style, blows my mind. 🤣 Way ahead of its time, and well built as well.

    • HPD1171
      HPD1171 3 meses atrás +7

      @Gil DE what are all these extra cables for? never mind just chuck them in the river.

    • David Zachmeyer
      David Zachmeyer 4 meses atrás +18

      With a single, six-foot-long hex wrench.

    • Gil DE
      Gil DE 5 meses atrás +16

      i wonder if they had the same aount of surplus parts and screws ....always happens to me, if i get something from ikea...:)

  • Steve Williams
    Steve Williams 5 meses atrás +181

    That bridge has a sibling in my home town of Shrewsbury! The bridge that goes over the river Severn from the quarry to the boathouse pub was built by the same company and wobbles possibly more than this one does. Looks almost identical too but ours is green (last time I saw it anyway)

    • Auravendill
      Auravendill 3 meses atrás +14

      @Moloxer Given that they ordered them from a catalogue, I would assume, that there are/were a few more.

    • Moloxer
      Moloxer 4 meses atrás +1

      Ok, so there are 2 more bridges like this.

    • Queeny
      Queeny 5 meses atrás +2

      Awesome

    • Matt Bosley
      Matt Bosley 5 meses atrás +18

      It's a more expensive, and wider, model but otherwise very similar. According to the Wiki the Shrewsbury bridge cost almost four times as much as the Cork bridge - 2,600 pounds in 1922.

    • Daniel Bamberger
      Daniel Bamberger 5 meses atrás +31

      Porthill Bridge. It even has its own Wikipedia article, which says: "Porthill Bridge experiences significant vibration, even when few people are crossing it - and has done since it was installed. Local pedestrians mostly accept this eccentricity as part of the bridge's charm."

  • Sarah Don't T[A]P Me!!
    Sarah Don't T[A]P Me!! 5 meses atrás +317

    I love that you could buy bridges from a catalogue at one point.

    • Josiah the NF
      Josiah the NF 5 meses atrás +15

      Oh what joy, a bot.

    • ShroudedWolf51
      ShroudedWolf51 5 meses atrás +13

      Used to for all sorts of things. My favorite story is the mail order houses from the Sears catalogue.
      If you're not familiar with the story, 99% Invisible podcast had an audio documentary on the topic in episode 323. I highly recommend it.

    • Ben Lovejoy
      Ben Lovejoy 5 meses atrás +25

      Next-level drunk eBay bidding ...

    • Andrew Suryali
      Andrew Suryali 5 meses atrás +45

      You still can. There are still companies specializing in prefab bridges like this one.

  • Duncan Booth
    Duncan Booth 5 meses atrás +64

    Shaky bridges are great. I remember many years ago when I was at school going across a suspension bridge in Scotland with a few friends. We decided to see what would happen if we walked in step. I think we managed about 3 steps in unison before realising just how bad an idea it was. It's really amazing how quickly the feedback builds up if you manage to match the resonant frequency of a bridge.

    • Neurofied Yamato
      Neurofied Yamato 2 meses atrás +1

      ​@A B You probably mean the Broughton Bridge collapse, which while the marching contributed to the collapse, the bridge was poorly constructed and failure was actually found to be inevitable. That led to breaking step when crossing bridges in the British and French armies. In France, marching at the Angers bridge's resonance frequency is only partially the cause of collapse too. The soldiers were actual already ordered NOT to march in cadence when crossing. But the bridge was poorly maintained and there was heavy winds. The various loads were the primary reason why Angers bridge collapsed so in both cases it was multiple contributing reasons.

    • A B
      A B 5 meses atrás +21

      Not sure if you're aware, but a French bridge collapsed after soldiers marched across it.
      Every army then ordered troops to break step as they went over bridges.

    • Duncan Booth
      Duncan Booth 5 meses atrás +16

      @David Hill it bounced so much it threw us in the air. Amazing just how quickly it built up.

    • David Hill
      David Hill 5 meses atrás +3

      Did you get it to bounce or swing?

  • Oberon4278
    Oberon4278 5 meses atrás +28

    This makes me absurdly happy. Not only that it's a really high quality bridge, but that it was able to arrive in boxes from a catalog, that people embraced the shake, and that the engineers (under direction of the public) rebuilt it to keep shaking.

  • Alan O'Connor
    Alan O'Connor 5 meses atrás +103

    As someone who grew up in Cork I've been delighted as a child and adult by the shake. Do more videos about Ireland please Tom.

  • Richard Harris
    Richard Harris 5 meses atrás +86

    Many years ago I was involved with ensuring the safety of a somewhat similar bridge. (A similar span but much wider, built for use by ponies and traps.) It was reported that it was bouncing to the extent that some pedestrians were concerned, so I calculated its natural frequency of vibration, as part of my investigation. The number I got was about two Hz (cycles per second), which is about normal footfall frequency for someone walking. This meant that someone walking at a steady pace that closely matched the natural frequency would set the bridge bouncing in just the same way as someone repeatedly pushing a child on a swing to make them go higher.
    Anyway, I could report that there was nothing to worry about, as long as a platoon of people marching in step didn't try to cross it.

    • Simon
      Simon 2 meses atrás +2

      good job you didn't publicly announce that or within 5 minutes there would've been a Facebook group made to accept the challenge.

    • Me (No, not Ashildr, I had the name before Doctor Who, and I'm not changing it!)
      Me (No, not Ashildr, I had the name before Doctor Who, and I'm not changing it!) 2 meses atrás

      Anyone up for a coordinated act of attempted destruction of public property? I think I'd really like to be part of a battalion of civilians whose sole purpose is looking snazzy while walking over an increasingly wobbly bridge.

    • Fetzie
      Fetzie 3 meses atrás +10

      @Constantine Petra Dewananda Haryanto Platoons are generally ordered to break step when crossing bridges of all kinds, because of what can happen if they don't :)

    • Rennie Ash
      Rennie Ash 3 meses atrás +1

      @Constantine Petra Dewananda Haryanto You'd hope that the bridge was designed to handle xtreme numbers of people including during resonance;p

    • DivineDawn
      DivineDawn 4 meses atrás +2

      @Constantine Petra Dewananda Haryanto this is an experiment we need...for science of course.

  • Tammy Leung
    Tammy Leung 2 meses atrás +4

    i love how whole bunch of very serious engineers, council members, historians etc worked very hard to keep it unnecessarily bouncy

  • Niilomaan
    Niilomaan 5 meses atrás +14

    Thank you. I know it's nothing but a silly little bridge I'll never see (or care to visit) but it made me smile. Getting a wholesome story like this in the middle of my news feed of scams, war and economical turmoil feels good.

  • Alexander o'callaghan
    Alexander o'callaghan 5 meses atrás +22

    Hey I'm from Cork and I was shocked and delighted to see you made a video in my hometown. Thank you! If you're still around I'll get you and the crew a pint!

  • Лев Ландау
    Лев Ландау 4 meses atrás +15

    you had me worried there for a moment that the bridge had to be demolished because it didn't meet EU standards. Glad they revived the bridge!

  • Unownshipper
    Unownshipper 3 meses atrás +6

    There's something honestly very sweet about a preservation that keeps the piece of history as it was, faults and all.

  • Darragh Gavin
    Darragh Gavin 5 meses atrás +21

    Brilliant video. As an Irishman myself, I’d love to see more videos of cork and Ireland as a whole. Even though I’ve crossed this bridge before, I didn’t know much of what was explained in the video.

  • Việt Lại Đắc
    Việt Lại Đắc 5 meses atrás +11

    I love how Tom keeps the video straight to the point and short. It is much more concise than many other channels trying to lengthen the video to earn more money.

    • ʟɛɛ ʝǟʍɛֆ
      ʟɛɛ ʝǟʍɛֆ Mês atrás

      I agree but there’s been a couple of videos I could of watch for a lot longer

  • crusinscamp
    crusinscamp 3 meses atrás +2

    Always interesting videos. I love the character of this structure. Where would our world be without people and things of character?

  • Shane Hendrick
    Shane Hendrick 4 meses atrás +11

    I am from Ireland and I’m 17 I could not count the amount of times I jumped of the Shaky bridge. One of the best feelings

  • Toganium
    Toganium 5 meses atrás +3347

    “This bridge doesn’t feel very safe. It feels wobbly.”
    “Good. That’s the point.”

    • JPhilB
      JPhilB 5 meses atrás +12

      Bridges, buildings, even airplanes are designed to flex and sway. If they didn't, they would snap off.

    • Piotr Kramer
      Piotr Kramer 5 meses atrás +1

      Alice from Well There's Your Problem disagrees with you. Make it more rigid.

    • knickglay
      knickglay 5 meses atrás

      Galloping Gertie has entered the chat

    • Matt N
      Matt N 5 meses atrás +3

      It's good that it doesn't feel safe...?

    • Autumn Rain
      Autumn Rain 5 meses atrás +9

      Toga pfp W

  • Charon's Ferry
    Charon's Ferry 3 meses atrás +3

    There used to be a little suspension bridge like this one in my hometown that had a similar rebuilding program, unfortunately they strengthened the towers so it doesn't shake anymore.

  • EatenByAGrue
    EatenByAGrue 5 meses atrás +86

    As an engineer, this isn't even in the top 10 of weird parameters I've had to design around.

    • EatenByAGrue
      EatenByAGrue 4 meses atrás +1

      @iWatchWithNoAds oh, yes. There are often very specific and seemingly strange parameters that come out of design review and risk analysis.

    • iWatchWithNoAds
      iWatchWithNoAds 4 meses atrás

      @EatenByAGrue that's a very specific requirement from regular businesses :O

    • EatenByAGrue
      EatenByAGrue 4 meses atrás +2

      @iWatchWithNoAds no, that would have probably been more fun though. It was a company that supplied businesses and governments with bathroom paraphernalia.

    • iWatchWithNoAds
      iWatchWithNoAds 4 meses atrás

      @EatenByAGrue for movies?

    • Queeny
      Queeny 5 meses atrás

      Wow which ones are

  • Alexander Alldritt
    Alexander Alldritt 5 meses atrás +12

    I find it amazing to see just how good historians the Irish are. Here in Australia you'd be lucky to find any material on the entire region I live in before the 1960s.

    • Brandon Donald Richards
      Brandon Donald Richards 3 meses atrás

      @Hairless Ape Same with America & for the same reason.

    • my yellow wise rug
      my yellow wise rug 4 meses atrás +1

      Check out Newgrange in County Meath... its one of this the oldest structures in the world constructed in 3200BC - Older than the pyramids and stonehenge.

    • Hairless Ape
      Hairless Ape 5 meses atrás +1

      I lived in England as a child and in Western Canada now. I wouldn't exactly say that Canada 'has no history', but it's so different. Canadian history as a country doesn't start until so late in English history, and so much was built so recently. Certainly no Roman roads or Stonehenge.

  • Clara -My New Private vidoe
    Clara -My New Private vidoe 5 meses atrás +19

    The idea that "If is doesn't shake, it will break" is also true for wooden roller coasters.

  • seblak
    seblak 5 meses atrás +1860

    Love to see people "testing" the bridge as the interview goes

    • 120spm
      120spm 5 meses atrás +19

      @The Leeside Snowman Never hurts to double check! 🌍

    • The Leeside Snowman
      The Leeside Snowman 5 meses atrás +26

      They won’t be testing it, they know it shakes. They’ll be doing it for the fun of it

  • Frank Mayer
    Frank Mayer 5 meses atrás +2

    That is so cool, that they kept it the way it was!
    A big thank you to the workers and engineers that restored this bridge to it‘s former glory! Keep up your great work!

  • Erik N
    Erik N 2 meses atrás +1

    We've a very similar, if shorter, wooden suspension bridge in my Maine hometown. The bounce in the center is quite strong and I remember my friends and I daring one another to cross. To this day, I can't cross it without a little shiver of thrill... And fear.

  • Lunabyes
    Lunabyes 27 dias atrás

    There's a bridge that did this in my hometown in rural New Zealand! It was also a protected structure with virtually the same rules as this one. It was made to wobble on purpose and it's been loved by all ages for decades :)

  • Ron Colvin
    Ron Colvin 4 meses atrás +4

    It's so refreshing to see the lack of Government inferences, keeping it real, with safety and fun. Thanks much for the video.

  • *:*: Hamster Muffin :*:*
    *:*: Hamster Muffin :*:* 5 meses atrás +21

    Love to see people "testing" the bridge as the interview goes

  • Clay Taylor
    Clay Taylor 3 meses atrás

    I love how you get to learn and understand the important difference between repair and preserve. Repair usually brings improvement but preservation means maintaining the status quo. Nice to see they made sure to preserve and not force the bridge to be repaired to modern specs and standards!

  • Alexander Harris
    Alexander Harris 5 meses atrás

    loving these videos on random things around the world! We in Britain feel compelled to keep things as they are if they're more than a certain number of years old, can't tell if it's respect for heritage or a loss of original thinking, maybe both...

  • Johnathon M. Palmer
    Johnathon M. Palmer 5 meses atrás +1

    I love the timing of how things happen as you or your family guests are talking about them.

  • Bring On The Beer
    Bring On The Beer 5 meses atrás +4187

    I'm having flashbacks to the radio episode of TechDif where Gary talked about the Americans unpacking London Bridge at Arizona and Tom mused on the existence of an IKEA flatpack bridge and here we are with an actual bridge bought from an actual catalogue and delivered in cardboard boxes!

    • Hideki Shinichi
      Hideki Shinichi 5 meses atrás +1

      I've seen exactly the same style bridge looking almost identical just shorter, and also wobbly af, in oslo norway just couple weeks ago.

    • turtledove
      turtledove 5 meses atrás

      @Danny Pipe Wrench I went there in 2020 I think when it was a comfortable day in hell. Decided to escape the heat of Phoenix, 😂. I don't know exactly what the temperature was, but we learned the valuable lesson that Lake Havasu City is not a place to go when Phoenix is sweltering.

    • johnmccnj
      johnmccnj 5 meses atrás +1

      I'm imagining a rather large allen key, along with some left over spare parts.

    • Ojisan
      Ojisan 5 meses atrás +2

      President Richard Nixon’s childhood home was bought by his father as a mail-order kit from the Sears Roebuck catalogue.

    • Vigilant Cosmic Penguin
      Vigilant Cosmic Penguin 5 meses atrás +2

      That's also how they do the construction of an IKEA building.

  • Shadowheart Art
    Shadowheart Art 5 meses atrás +2

    I love that preservation is an important consideration in some projects =)
    Not everything needs to be "fixed"

  • Johnny
    Johnny 4 meses atrás +2

    The construction company that did the repair did a really good job.

  • GazubaGames
    GazubaGames 5 meses atrás +1

    I visited that bridge years ago, I didn't even realise there was a story, nor did I know that it was supposed to be shaky. Cool video Tom.

  • Jski
    Jski 4 meses atrás +1

    I actually really wish there was some bridge like this on my daily walk. I could easily see it bringing a smile to my face every time I cross.

  • A. Rudesill
    A. Rudesill 5 meses atrás +7369

    I love the idea of a bridge catalogue. I need one in my life

    • Brian Garrow
      Brian Garrow Mês atrás

      At one point, you could order single family dwellings from a Sears and Roebuck Catalog. The entire house would be packaged in a couple of boxcars and shipped to your town or city, where your contractor could pick up the materials and assemble your new home.

    • Auravendill
      Auravendill 3 meses atrás

      @MLeoDaalder I'm not familiar with Sears, but in the 60s you could order houses from Quelle (in Germany). There is one in a museum (Freilichtmuseum Kommern) in a state very close to its original, that one can enter and look around.

    • Clam Tram
      Clam Tram 5 meses atrás

      @DECODED The sears house catalogues started well before the 1900s and were big around then and a bit after ww1 for repayment to soldiers and their families with farming land (atleast was done alot here in Australia to returning soldiers even in ww2 had a similar premise). More to do with mass migration to areas around a country, either farming land, industrially wealthy towns or on the outskirts of a city or major transport artery. Shame theres nothing like it now outside of preordered granny flats and sheds due to companies and cities monopolising on houses and even regulstions (some understandable, most just ridiculous)

    • Van da
      Van da 5 meses atrás

      Me too :)

    • Dillon Qaphsiel
      Dillon Qaphsiel 5 meses atrás

      You used to be able to buy house out of made to order catalogs.

  • The Dig Bick
    The Dig Bick 5 meses atrás

    I am currently taking a class in vibrations and all throughout the video I was thinking “oh no it’s gonna be another Tacoma Bridge incident”, but I was pleasantly surprised to find out that the engineers intentionally left in the vibrations! I assume that since this bridge is on a much smaller scale when compared to the Tacoma Bridge, the engineers were able to get away with integrating the vibrations instead of damping them. Super interesting stuff!

  • Aidan McGovern
    Aidan McGovern 5 meses atrás

    Great video! Delighted to see our world-class bridge getting international recognition!

  • Wisconsin.pikachu
    Wisconsin.pikachu 5 meses atrás +10

    What's sad is we have a old rail bridge built in 1908 that was converted to a 1 lane vehicle bridge, closed in 2017 and scheduled to be destroyed this year :( I wish it could be saved as a walk bridge but the city ignored the people and will tear it down and the new bridge to replace it isn't even going in the same area

  • D. Byers
    D. Byers 5 meses atrás +1

    All suspension bridges move to some extent. Walking across the Brooklyn Bridge on a windy evening I can feel it move. The Tacoma Narrows Bridge in Washington State had a wild wobble which caused to collapse in the 1940s I believe. But for any lawyers in the viewing audience, please define a "legal wobble." I can see an illegal wobble by standing outside a pub on a Friday night. Cheers!

  • rendring
    rendring 5 meses atrás +2298

    As a person who lives and grew up in Cork, I went to this park all of the time as a kid. It's really nice to see coverage of the much beloved shakey bridge when all we ever get tourism for is the Blarney Kissing Stone. Shakey bridge is honestly way more fun and genuine to the Cork experience. Thank you Tom :)

    • Noelf
      Noelf 5 meses atrás +1

      Although I'm a "Sorrie" I did cross the Shakey Bridge many times going up to Sundays Well!...And indeed, many happy days were had on the swings and the slide in Fitzgerald's Park!...and do you remember when they used to have bands playing in the bandstand? 😁... Happy days!

    • Lily Was Here
      Lily Was Here 5 meses atrás +1

      @Jsaysyay you went there in 2019 or in 1919?

    • Moody Blues
      Moody Blues 5 meses atrás +3

      I've never been there, but this is exactly why the bridge does indeed need to be preserved as is. As long as it's safe of course, which it already was for nearly a century, so that seems easy enough. If this bridge would've been identical looking but not wobbly anymore, it would straight away lose all its appeal. It's not a good looking bridge, so its one standout feature is the wobble. And if I'm somewhat in the area, this might be a fun little trip to take on holidays, but again: not if the wobble wasn't there.

    • Jsaysyay
      Jsaysyay 5 meses atrás +3

      can't believe in '19 when i stayed there for a bit, i was like a five minute walk from it, and didn't know/visit it, would've loved to have been on it

    • Atriya Koller
      Atriya Koller 5 meses atrás

      How aren't you afraid when you're on it though? I once walked along a shakey bridge and all I could think of was "please don't make me fall down". Granted, the shake was more sideways, the up and down shake was less pronounced, but still...I barely made it and then I took another route to the same destination to avoid the shakey bridge

  • Caedmon Johnson
    Caedmon Johnson 5 meses atrás +2

    Not just old bridges wobble, there’s a reasonably modern pedestrian one over the river Taff in Cardiff that bounces up and down when you walk over it, feels very odd if you’re on a bike and a person walking across starts it moving!

  • Lord Watermelon
    Lord Watermelon 5 meses atrás +2

    I’ve been over that bridge many times and jumping on it feels terrifying!

  • Benjamin Smith
    Benjamin Smith 5 meses atrás +4

    This is why I love Tom Scott videos, even something as mundane as a bridge has ab interesting story to be told

    • Hairless Ape
      Hairless Ape 5 meses atrás

      Objection. Bridges can be fascinating. The vast majority of things that people make are less exciting than the coolest bridges. Maybe you have to be a bit of a nerd.

  • Alan Bugler
    Alan Bugler 5 meses atrás

    There are a few bridges in Inverness that do exactly the same. They look fairly similar in design too. I remember bouncing them as a child, much to the annoyance and terror of some people trying to cross them. The ones in Inverness are a good bit older than this one, and I saw one of them collapse in the 90s.

  • Daniel Smith
    Daniel Smith 5 meses atrás

    Yet another one of your videos that just stop me in my tracks....make me think, make me consider the unintended consequences of design. Thank you, Tom Scott.

  • MarkJT1000
    MarkJT1000 3 meses atrás

    Totally trivial, but another really interesting bit of history. Brought as usual by Tom in his easy, informative yet light hearted manner.

  • David Nwokoye
    David Nwokoye 5 meses atrás +5

    I've been on that bridge. My college is literally like 2 mins away from it. It's crazy to see this on here

  • Séamus Ryan
    Séamus Ryan 5 meses atrás

    Fantastic to see a video on such an iconic place in the City I've lived my whole life in. I hope you enjoyed your stay, however short, in the region.

  • Josh
    Josh 5 meses atrás +1091

    As an Irishman, I’ve been to this bridge. It’s very unnerving, especially when you don’t know beforehand that it shakes.

    • Jon Donnelly
      Jon Donnelly 5 meses atrás +1

      @CRAZY I'm not really fun.

    • Jaqui Greenlees
      Jaqui Greenlees 5 meses atrás +1

      You don't know it shakes and you have an absolute terror of heights then cross the bridge.
      lucky me heights don't bother me but I know plenty of people who they do.

    • steem lenn
      steem lenn 5 meses atrás +3

      If you think that is unnerving - there is a walkway (a glass floor "bridge" over a deep ravine) I think in China where one part is actually a screen (-like) that shows a shattering of the glass floor when someone walks on it, complete with sound.
      Not a sightseeing spot you should bring someone with a heart condition.

    • Patrick Linehan
      Patrick Linehan 5 meses atrás

      @SlierFox the shaky bridge is in Cork, so feck off with yer jackeen muck (Guinness). In Cork it's either Murphys or Beamish!!

    • CRAZY
      CRAZY 5 meses atrás +3

      @Jon Donnelly thats no fun

  • Hugo Stiglitz
    Hugo Stiglitz 3 meses atrás +1

    Imagine getting something as complicated as a bridge from a catalogue like Amazon or Ikea, that lasts 100 years and at the end of that 100 years its repairable for another 100 years.
    I dont think so!

  • SUSSY- 🔥𝐆𝐨 𝐓𝐨 𝐌𝐲 𝐂𝐡𝐚𝐧𝐧𝐞𝐥 [𝐋!𝐯𝐞]🔞

    Used to jump off this bridge during the summer when I was younger, even climbed to the top of one of the towers and jumped in to the river, good fun, thanks for showing it to the world Tom👍

  • Snek
    Snek 5 meses atrás +26

    People just want to have fun shaking their bridge

  • Notsocoolio
    Notsocoolio 5 meses atrás

    There was one of these in Maine that me and my friends randomly came across. We were very weirded out when it moved when we stepped on it until we read the signs.

  • SovietOnion
    SovietOnion 5 meses atrás +968

    Haha, the circle around the guy jumping on the bridge got me!
    Though, to be fair, if I lived nearby to it, I'd probably do the same thing every time I cross it.

    • imsmol and angery
      imsmol and angery 5 meses atrás

      I've never had a reason to cross it but as a child I jumped on it almost every time I was near by, and a a few times as an adult as well

    • Z Stoner
      Z Stoner 5 meses atrás +7

      @Finbarr Ryan There should be a sign next to the bridge that says: "Patrons from ages 3 to 103 are hereby permitted to jump on this span."

    • sirBrouwer
      sirBrouwer 5 meses atrás +2

      @Gojira_breathes_ no encourage them. if they are jumping they can't or at least it's very hard to drink. I mean before and after sure but during the jump.

    • Felix Babœuf
      Felix Babœuf 5 meses atrás +23

      @Finbarr Ryan There's no reason for adulthood to be the absence of fun. Bounce on, Ryan...

    • Gojira_breathes_
      Gojira_breathes_ 5 meses atrás +26

      @Finbarr Ryan “Ryan! Please stop jumping on the bridge, you aren’t a kid anymore!”
      Ryan: “I must…keep…bouncing…”

  • rebel cork vanlife
    rebel cork vanlife 2 meses atrás

    Tom, I hope you spent a nice bit of time around Cork. There's Alot of unusual stuff there. We have a cannon buried face down on the side of a road where ships used to more up. Cork was like Venice

  • The HairyFifaPlayer
    The HairyFifaPlayer 3 meses atrás

    Great to see you in Ireland. I'd love to see more of my country featured.

  • FuZe Moxit
    FuZe Moxit 5 meses atrás +4

    Legal wobbling as opposed to the bridge illegally wobbling seems unnaturally funny to me

  • TheDiMono
    TheDiMono 5 meses atrás

    When I was in Inverness in 2014 I was told by my host that there are bouncy bridges in the city. So I found one and did burpees on it. It was lots of fun. And very challenging.

  • Daniel
    Daniel 5 meses atrás +678

    As a Cork person, I can say that yes, the bridge is shakey. Also Cork has a butter museum.

    • Arianrhod Hyde
      Arianrhod Hyde 2 meses atrás

      I've been to the butter museum twice, it's well worth a visit. You can make your own butter labels and sometimes they do butter making demonstrations. There's also a lot of information about butter related folklore. The staff are lovely too and left me and my friends come in for free near the end of the day.

    • Gerarda Cronin
      Gerarda Cronin 5 meses atrás +3

      @Chuck Scott Corkonian.

    • Chuck Scott
      Chuck Scott 5 meses atrás

      A person from Cork: Corkian or Corker? 🤔

    • Colin Newman
      Colin Newman 5 meses atrás

      @Michiel Werring you would need to go to Portugal for that. They dont grow cork trees in Ireland.

    • Gerarda Cronin
      Gerarda Cronin 5 meses atrás +3

      @Michiel Werring No, the cork museum is in the Algarve in Portugal and I have visited it. Cork trees do not grow in Ireland. The city of Cork, Ireland is so called because it is built on a marsh (Corcach in Irish). As a Corkonian, I regularly visited Fitzgerald’s Park as a child and jumped up and down on the Shakey Bridge. The Park does contain the Cork Public Museum, which focuses on the history of the city. I’m delighted the Shakey Bridge has been properly restored and kudos to Tom for featuring it!

  • Jonathan M0JSX
    Jonathan M0JSX Mês atrás

    I walked over the bridge on Saturday (twice). I’m happy to confirm that the shake is still there (however I didn’t count the cycles/second)

  • Do I Know You
    Do I Know You 5 meses atrás

    Glad to see you on my home turf! We're proud of our Shakey bridge. There's a fun urban legend children tell each other that if a cat crosses that bridge it'll vibrate so much that it explodes.

  • Kieran McCarthy
    Kieran McCarthy 5 meses atrás

    Many thanks Tom! great to meet you; don't be a stranger to Cork and Ireland again! Keep up the amazing work!

  • GeneralRandom1
    GeneralRandom1 5 meses atrás

    Tom's last few videos have just been incredible. Gold standard.

  • JenLF Potter38
    JenLF Potter38 5 meses atrás

    The bridge on the A325 just down the hill from where I used to live and where my mum still lives now, that is a solid railway bridge, doesn't move out of the way for HGVs ignoring the signs and smashing into it. I'm surprised its still standing. I think it could and should possibly, be replaced with a level crossing there so HGVs could just drive over the track rather than smashing a bridge.

  • November OrWhatever
    November OrWhatever 5 meses atrás +1

    2:41 That is exactly what I would be doing if I lived there. Glad that "Wobbly bridges are fun" is a popular opinion

  • Diago767
    Diago767 5 meses atrás +1

    Hey Tom, there's a very similar bridge across the river in inverness that I grew up bouncing across, I think it might be even older though, it was locally referred to as "the bouncy bridge"

  • Tomáš Kotrejch
    Tomáš Kotrejch 5 meses atrás

    In a nearby town in my country over (a much thinner) river there is a suspension bridge so bouncy it's like a giant trampoline.
    I felt quite bad doing so but I've been bouncing up and down a good meter for about 15 minutes there.

  • Brian Irwin
    Brian Irwin 5 meses atrás +762

    If you took the shake out of the Shaky Bridge you'd just have a bridge. I'm glad you gave this coverage, Tom, it's a rare example of Cork City Council doing something completely right. It's 5 minutes from University College Cork as well so generations of students have made the pilgrimage to come and bounce on it - myself included!

    • Alastair Ward
      Alastair Ward 5 meses atrás +6

      If you took the shake out of it you wouldn't have a bridge at all.

  • YOEL _44
    YOEL _44 5 meses atrás +1

    Leiro -> Galicia -> Spain, it has a way shakier bridge.
    I understand that the story of its restoration and whatnot is what's interesting here, but the shakiness itself is a common feature of small pedestrian bridges.

  • FrobozzElectric
    FrobozzElectric 5 meses atrás

    In Portland, Oregon we also have a bridge we call the Bouncy Bridge on the campus of Reed College. It bounces because it was made super long with two bends in its path because it runs over a protected nature area and was designed to minimize its impact on the area.

  • Ber O'Riordan
    Ber O'Riordan 4 meses atrás +2

    Thanks for the video Tom! I grew up in Cork and spent many a Sunday afternoon jumping on the bridge. Have since moved to England and haven’t seen the refurbishment. It’s looking fantastic!

  • Luke Maurer
    Luke Maurer 5 meses atrás

    As someone from a long line of people who love keeping old stuff around, this makes me extremely happy. The Shaky Bridge is shaky and so shaky it shall remain! (Given that it's actually perfectly safe as it is, of course.)

  • Joseph Oliveira
    Joseph Oliveira 5 meses atrás +349

    50,000 euro for a bridge that held up for 90 years before needing refurbishment? Kieran McCarthy's right, that bridge WAS good value.

    • imsmol and angery
      imsmol and angery 5 meses atrás

      As a person from Cork I can say we love a bargain

    • Paul Frederick
      Paul Frederick 5 meses atrás

      No that bridge will remain a good value until the end of time.

    • vegiimite
      vegiimite 5 meses atrás +6

      If you are selling enough bridges to need a catalog you are probably making multiples of the same components which means that tooling costs are spread over many bridges. Also that is the cost of materials only, not the on site installation including the foundations.

    • Matthew Malthouse
      Matthew Malthouse 5 meses atrás +8

      @Vera de Wolf I haven't the faintest idea how one would go about doing an in-depth comparative costing, but someone will know and I'd love to see it. The details of how relative costs change over the long term is fascinating and can provide insights into both economic and social history that headline figures for generalised inflation don't even hint at.

    • Vera de Wolf
      Vera de Wolf 5 meses atrás +4

      The price of labour has increased a lot, but we have cnc machines, calculators, and other computery thingies now so that's cool.

  • ALD Productions
    ALD Productions Mês atrás

    I really appreciate that this one unintended feature was significant enough to be preserved.

  • NoEsUnYoutuber
    NoEsUnYoutuber Mês atrás

    The idea of a massive public bridge being bought from a catalog and arriving in boxes is insane.

  • gestaltbravo
    gestaltbravo 5 meses atrás +1

    The bridge over Tallulah Gorge, more specifically the footbridge over Hurricane Falls at Tallulah Gorge shakes quite a bit too when walked on. It like this bridge in Cork is a suspension bridge, however it has a wooden deck and railing on it. I recall watching it being built from the gorge rim when I was a kid as I grew up not too far from the gorge.

  • Gregie
    Gregie 5 meses atrás

    Well done @tom Scott! Brilliant ro see you commentate on an Irish project that challenges the u know! There are 100s of projects along these principles jn ireland!

  • Aliguar
    Aliguar 5 meses atrás +928

    Tom jumping on a bridge is something I didn't know i needed in my life.

  • Kamel
    Kamel 5 meses atrás

    You should cover some of the private bridges in rural Appalachia - scariest thing I've ever done in my life is cross one of those.

  • Jubilant Fae
    Jubilant Fae 5 meses atrás +2

    That's where me and my partner's love lock used to be. We grew up really close to that area! It was there for like 6 years until the council removed all the locks :o

  • Rainbow Nati
    Rainbow Nati 5 meses atrás

    I believe you could find a lot of incredibly wobbly bridges all over Europe.
    I happen to know a few, most of which move from side to side in the order of several centimetres as people walk on it and as the wind blows.
    However, I must admit that this is an intriguing piece of history, indeed.

  • Liam Meighan
    Liam Meighan 5 meses atrás

    Great to see Tom visiting my second home! The Shakey Bridge is a Cork landmark. I've been on the bridge both before and after reconstruction, and the shake has remained constant. Thanks for shining a light on this lovely little idiosyncracy in bridge building :)

  • Richard Edwards
    Richard Edwards 5 meses atrás +521

    The idea that "If is doesn't shake, it will break" is also true for wooden roller coasters.

    • Erik Giesen Loo
      Erik Giesen Loo 5 meses atrás +1

      of all structures, really. Forces cause stresses, and stresses can cause strains (and thus) displacements. Rigid boundary conditions that restrict these displacements can result in even higher stresses, possibly in excess of a materials compressive or tensile strength.

    • _qwe_FK_1
      _qwe_FK_1 5 meses atrás +31

      every structures shakes if there is a dynamic load or a sudden load

    • blindleader42
      blindleader42 5 meses atrás +59

      Steel roller coasters too. Just with very different frequency and amplitude.

  • Jade Cairney
    Jade Cairney 5 meses atrás

    There’s a bridge like this in a park in my area (north Ayrshire Scotland) it’s always fun to surprise people who have never been over it before by bouncing in the middle while walking over with them

  • Marvin De Bot
    Marvin De Bot 5 meses atrás

    When it comes to easy repair there are some advantages of your bridge having come as a kit.

  • Aero storm
    Aero storm 5 meses atrás

    The bridge (about the same size too) in the Kansas City Zoo is the same type of bridge and can sway/shake quiet a lot. Usually people who cross it try to purposefully shake it.

  • Leo
    Leo 5 meses atrás

    A few years back I lived in a small town (village?) in Western Norway. Down at the beach where the local river goes into the fjord, there's a small forested area with a short suspension bridge over the river. That thing swings and bounces like an amusement park ride, so much so that my dog was terrified of walking across. Kids like to prank each other by promising not to shake the bridge, and then jumping like crazy. You can really lose your balance if you're not expecting it.

  • Adtpg
    Adtpg 5 meses atrás +327

    Love how people wrote in to make sure the repaired bring still shook, little things like that really make the world more fun and interesting!

    • iabervon
      iabervon 5 meses atrás +25

      I'm imagining the engineer jumping up and down on the bridge before and after repair to characterize and validate the historical shakiness of the bridge. "Sorry, can't attend your meeting. I'm scheduled to jump on a bridge in Cork at that time."